Journal Article

·2022

Predicting Patent Quality Based on Machine Learning Approach

Zülfiye Erdoğan , Serkan Altuntaş YTU , Türkay Dereli

IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management

Abstract

The investment budget allocated by companies in R&D activities has increased due to increased competition in the market. Applications for industrial property rights by countries, investors, companies, and universities to protect inventions obtained as an outcome of investments have also increased. The selection of the patent to be invested becomes more difficult with the increasing number of applications. Therefore, predicting patent quality is quite significant for companies to be successful in the future. The level to which a patent meets the expectations of decision makers is referred to as patent quality. Patent indices represent decision makers' expectations. In this study, an approach is proposed to predict patent quality in practice. The proposed approach uses supervised learning algorithms and analytic hierarchy process (AHP) method. The proposed approach is applied to patents related to personal digital assistant technologies. The performances of individual and ensemble machine learning methods have been also analyzed to establish the prediction model. In addition, 75% split ratio and the five-fold cross-validation methods have been used to verify the prediction model. The multilayer perceptron algorithm has 76% accuracy value. The proposed prediction model is essential in directing R&D studies to the right technology areas and transferring the incentives to patent applications with a high quality rate.

Keywords

Analytic hierarchy process Quality (philosophy) Intellectual property Machine learning Incentive Investment (military) Competition (biology) Artificial intelligence Multilayer perceptron Computer science Patent analysis Process (computing) Engineering Artificial neural network Operations research Economics Data science

Subject Areas

Intellectual Property and Patents ·Management of Technology and Innovation ·Social Sciences

Citations by Year

Related YTU Activities

Sustainability activities and projects connected to this article.

General · 2025 Technical Universities Association
General · 2025 9th International Aluminum Technologies, Machinery and Products Trade Fair and 13th Aluminum Symposium
General · 2025 Defense Industry Summit 2025 (SSZ'25)
General · 2025 Yıldız BEST Engineering Competition & Technology Summit
General · 2025 Yıldız Jam: 3rd Game Development Summit and Competition
General · 2025 Lagari UAV Team
General · 2025 YTU and ASFAT (Military Factories and Shipyard Operations Inc.) Cooperation Protocol
General · 2025 Cappadocia IP’25 Intellectual Property Days
General · 2025 Patent Application Strategies for Software-Based Inventions Seminar
General · 2025 Koluman Automotive: Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights Workshop
General · 2025 Berdan Cıvata: Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights Workshop
General · 2025 Awareness Series: “The Journey of Invention and Intellectual Property in Engineering”
General · 2025 Artificial Intelligence and Copyright Seminar
General · 2025 NVIDIA Inception Capital Connect: Artificial Intelligence Innovation and Investor Meeting
General · 2025 TÜBİTAK 2244 Industrial Doctorate Programme: YTU and Ford Otosan Cooperation
General · 2025 ISIF 2025: Nine Medals and a Special Award at the International Invention Fair
General · 2025 Global Success in 3D Display Technologies
General · 2025 Future Talent Summit
General · 2025 E-Comm & Beyond: E-Commerce and Marketing Summit
General · 2025 İşin Mutfağı: Digital Media & Industry Leader Office Visits
General · 2025 FLO Technology Internship Program
General · 2025 Top 100 Turkish AI Startups & Investor Meeting
General · 2025 Applied Cybersecurity Training with Pure7: Incident Response and Digital Forensics
General · 2025 Bize De Anlatır Mısın?: Digital Competency & Certification Programme
General · 2025 Web of Science Research Assistant Trial Access
General · 2025 ScienceDirect AI Trial Access
General · 2025 YÖK Research Universities Performance Ranking 2024
General · 2025 Success of the Faculty of Mechanical Engineering in TÜBİTAK 2209 Programs
General · 2025 Shape D-Future Competition
Education · 2024 ECONENGIN Project (Economic Engineering)
Education · 2024 CASE Yıldız’24: National Case Analysis Competition Held at YTU on April 29–30, 2024
Education · 2024 Academia of Marketing: “Four Themes, One Journey — Shaping the Future!”
Education · 2024 Stock Market and Technical Analysis Training from A1 Capital
Education · 2024 Digital Gaming Days Reborn”: YTU Celebrates the Future of Interactive Technologies
Education · 2024 Shaping the Future of Entrepreneurship: Insights from Veli Bahçeci at YTU MiNT
Education · 2024 YTU Hosts Marketing+ Summit to Explore the Future of Marketing and Digital Transformation
Education · 2024 "YTU Hosts Seminar on Quality Management Systems in Biomedical Engineering"
Education · 2024 "YTU Biomedical Engineering Department Organizes Seminar on Central Operations Management"
Education · 2024 FSMH 101: Entrepreneurship and Intellectual Property
Education · 2024 Fostering Future Innovators: YTU Integrates Applied Learning Opportunities for YTU Schools Students