Journal Article

·2025 OPEN ACCESS

USABILITY vs. ECOLOGY: DEFINING GOOD DESIGN FROM DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES

Umut Burcu Tasa YTU

Akdeniz-sanat/Akdeniz sanat dergisi

Abstract

This paper investigates the interplay between usability and ecological design in the context of interactive media, seeking to address the challenge of integrating these frameworks into design practices. While usability has long been a cornerstone of Human-Computer Interaction design by emphasizing user-centered metrics, ecological design advocates for a more holistic perspective that transcends anthropocentric views. By comparing the System Usability Scale with the Ecological Systems Scale, this research evaluates the effectiveness of integrating ecological heuristics into usability-focused design processes. The findings reveal a correlation between usability and ECOS scores, suggesting that foundational design capabilities are essential for successful ecological design implementation. Perceived conflicts between usability and ecological principles were attributed to the fast consumption demands of the media design industry rather than intrinsic contradictions. This study advocates for the development of educational frameworks that support ongoing discussions and iterative revisions in design processes. Ultimately, it aims to contribute to a more sustainable design practice that balances user needs with ecological integrity.

Keywords

Usability Heuristic evaluation Computer science Cornerstone Usability engineering Web usability Anthropocentrism Context (archaeology) User-centered design Usability goals Heuristics Human–computer interaction Knowledge management Ecology Geography

Subject Areas

Innovative Human-Technology Interaction ·Human-Computer Interaction ·Physical Sciences
Usability and User Interface Design ·Human-Computer Interaction ·Physical Sciences
Innovative Approaches in Technology and Social Development ·Management of Technology and Innovation ·Social Sciences